Why “Healthy Eating” Messages Can Be Harmful for Kids

Teaching children about food is important, but overemphasizing "healthy eating" messages can unintentionally create food anxieties, disordered eating behaviors, and negative body image. What starts as a well-intentioned effort to promote health can lead to rigid food rules, guilt around eating certain foods, and an unhealthy relationship with food.

The Problem with Over-Simplified “Healthy Eating” Messages

·         Labels foods as “Good” or “Bad”

o   Phrases like “This food is healthy, and this one is unhealthy” can make children fear certain foods

o   Kids may feel guilt or shame if they eat something perceived as “bad” (e.g., candy, chips, or desserts)

·         Encourages rigid thinking about food

o   Children may develop an all-or-nothing mindset where they feel they must eat "perfectly" to be “healthy.”

o   This can lead to anxiety around eating or avoiding entire food groups like carbs or fats

·         Puts too much focus on weight and appearance

o   Messages framed around "healthy eating" are often tied to weight loss or avoiding weight gain, which can make children overly concerned about their bodies

o   Body dissatisfaction is a major risk factor for developing eating disorders

How “Healthy Eating” Messages Contribute to Disordered Eating

·         Fear of “Unhealthy” Foods

o   Children may start avoiding foods they perceive as unhealthy, which can spiral into restrictive eating patterns

·         Early Dieting Behaviors

o   Messages like “don’t eat too much sugar” can lead to calorie counting, excessive food control, or skipping meals

·         Guilt and Shame

o   If a child eats something deemed “unhealthy,” they may feel they’ve “failed,” leading to emotional distress around food choices

·         Disrupted Hunger Cues

o   Overemphasizing what to eat (or not eat) can prevent kids from listening to their natural hunger and fullness signals, resulting in overeating or under-eating

Examples of Potentially Harmful “Healthy Eating” Messages

·         "Sugar is bad for you."

o   Why it's harmful: This can make kids fear sweet treats and feel guilty for enjoying birthday cake or other celebratory foods

·         "You should always finish your vegetables before dessert."

o   Why it's harmful: This reinforces the idea that vegetables are an obligation while desserts are “bad” but desirable

·         "Don’t eat too much or you’ll gain weight."

o   Why it's harmful: This links food directly to weight, teaching kids to fear weight gain and equate it with failure

·         "We don’t eat junk food in this house."

o   Why it's harmful: Kids may feel ashamed or anxious if they encounter “junk food” elsewhere (e.g., at a friend’s house)

What Happens When Kids Develop Food Fears?

When children internalize negative or overly rigid “healthy eating” messages, they may:

·         Develop Eating Disorders:

o   Orthorexia (obsession with eating “clean”) or ARFID (Avoidant/Restrictive Food Intake Disorder) can stem from extreme fear of "unhealthy" foods

o   Risk of anorexia nervosa if the child starts equating restriction with health and control

·         Struggle with Growth and Development:

o   Avoiding entire food groups (e.g., carbs or fats) can lead to nutritional deficiencies, stunted growth, or delayed puberty

·         Experience Social Isolation:

o   Fear of “unhealthy” foods may lead to avoiding social situations like birthday parties or sleepovers where those foods are served

How to Promote Positive Messages About Food

·         Focus on Balance, Not Rules

o   Teach kids that all foods can fit into a balanced diet

§  Instead of “Sugar is bad,” say, “Cookies are a treat we enjoy sometimes, and that’s okay.”

§  Encourage variety: “Your body needs different foods to help you grow, play, and stay strong.”

o   Avoid Weight-Based Language

·         Never link food to weight gain or loss

·         Instead, focus on how food helps the body:

o   “This sandwich gives you energy to play soccer.”

o   “Milk helps your bones grow strong.”

·         Emphasize Listening to Hunger Cues

o   Encourage kids to recognize when they’re hungry, full, or satisfied

§  “It’s okay to stop eating when you’re full.”

§  “If you’re hungry again later, we can eat more.”

·         Model a Positive Relationship with Food

o   Be a role model by eating a variety of foods without guilt or restrictive behaviors

o   Avoid saying things like, “I shouldn’t eat this dessert,” or “I need to burn off those calories.”

Healthy Eating Without the Harmful Messaging

Key Messages to Teach Kids About Food

• "All foods give us energy—some help us grow, and some are just fun to enjoy."

• "Your body knows what it needs—trust it to tell you when you’re hungry or full."

• "Food is fuel for your brain, muscles, and body."

• "It’s okay to enjoy a treat; all foods have a place in your diet."

Focus on Fun and Enjoyment

• Involve kids in cooking and grocery shopping to teach them about food in a positive way.

• Let them explore new foods without pressure—this builds confidence and curiosity.

Conclusion: Building a Healthy Relationship with Food

Overly rigid "healthy eating" messages can unintentionally harm kids by creating fear, guilt, and disordered eating habits. Instead, promote balance, flexibility, and body positivity to help children develop a healthy, lifelong relationship with food.

By modeling positive attitudes and focusing on how food helps the body, parents can protect their children from diet culture and promote both physical and emotional well-being.

Conversation Starters & Books to Promote a Positive Relationship with Food & Body Image in Kids

Using age-appropriate language and engaging stories can help children develop a healthy, balanced view of food and body image without fear or guilt. Below are some conversation starters and recommended books to encourage body acceptance, mindful eating, and self-esteem.

Conversation Starters for Kids (Preschool to Preteen)

·         Encouraging a Positive Food Relationship

o   “Did you know that food is like fuel for our bodies? Some foods give us energy to run and play, and others help our brains think clearly!”

o   “What’s your favorite food, and how does it make you feel when you eat it?”

o   “Let’s try a new food today—what do you think it will taste like?”

o   What This Does: Helps kids understand food as nourishment, energy, and enjoyment, rather than something to fear or control

·         Talking About Body Image & Self-Worth

o   “Our bodies do so many amazing things—what’s something cool your body can do?

o    “Did you know people come in all different shapes and sizes? Every body is special in its own way.”

o    “What are some things that make you feel strong and happy, besides how you look?”

o   What This Does: Reinforces body appreciation and self-worth beyond appearance

·         Media & Social Media Awareness

o   “Have you ever noticed that cartoons and movies often show only one kind of body type? What do you think about that?”

o   “Did you know that some pictures in magazines and on social media are edited to look different from real life?”

o   “How do you feel after watching certain shows or scrolling online? Let’s talk about it!”What This Does: Helps kids become critical thinkers about unrealistic beauty standards and digital media influences.

Best Books for Kids on Positive Food & Body Image

·         Books About Food & Mindful Eating

o   I Can Eat a Rainbow" – Olena Rose

§  Teaches kids about eating colorful foods for health, not restriction

o   Spoonful of Sweetness: And Other Delicious Manners" – Maria Dismondy

§  Encourages joyful eating and family mealtimes

o   How to Feed Your Parents" – Ryan Miller

§  A fun book that encourages kids to try new foods without pressure or fear

o   Full Mouse, Empty Mouse" – Dina Zeckhausen

o   Helps kids understand hunger and fullness cues in a fun way

·         Books about body positivity and self-acceptance

o   Bodies Are Cool" – Tyler Feder

§  Celebrates body diversity in a fun and colorful way

o   You Are Enough" – Margaret O'Hair

§  A story about self-acceptance, diversity, and kindness

• Her Body Can" – Katie Crenshaw & Ady Meschke

• A book that teaches girls their bodies are powerful, no matter their shape or size

• My Body is Amazing" – Dr. Dawn Huebner

• Helps kids understand that bodies are for moving, learning, and having fun—not just looking a certain way.

·         Books for older kids and teens (body image and media awareness)

o   The Body Image Book for Girls: Love Yourself and Grow Up Fearless" – Charlotte Markey

§  A great guide for preteens and teens on confidence and self-love

o   Love Your Body" – Jessica Sanders

§  Empowers girls to respect and appreciate their bodies, not compare them

o   More Than a Body: Your Body is an Instrument, Not an Ornament" – Lexie & Lindsay Kite

§  Encourages teens to focus on what their bodies can do rather than how they look

o   "Starfish" – Lisa Fipps (Fiction Book)

§  A middle-grade novel about self-acceptance and overcoming body shaming.

Final Thoughts: How Parents Can Reinforce Positive Messages

·         Be a Role Model – Avoid talking about your own diet, weight, or body dissatisfaction in front of kids

·         Use Neutral Food Language – Instead of saying, “We can’t eat junk food,” say “All foods give us energy in different ways.”

·         Praise Kids for Who They Are, Not How They Look – Compliment kindness, creativity, and effort, rather than appearance

·         Encourage Media Literacy – Talk to kids about how social media and ads manipulate body standards

·         By focusing on self-acceptance, balance, and joyful eating, we can help kids build a lifelong healthy relationship with food and their bodies

Bottom of Form

Disclaimer: This information is intended for educational purposes and should not replace professional medical advice. If you or someone you know is in crisis or needs immediate help, please contact a healthcare professional or crisis intervention service immediately.